1018 vs 1045 Steel

1018 and 1045 are common carbon steels that differ mainly in carbon content. That single difference drives their strength, hardness, and how they are best used.

Property undefined undefined
Carbon content 0.18% 0.45%
Yield strength (cold drawn) 370 MPa (54 ksi) 530 MPa (77 ksi)
Tensile (cold drawn) 440 MPa (64 ksi) 625 MPa (91 ksi)
Hardness About 126 HB 170 to 200 HB
Weldability Excellent Fair, preheat helps
Heat treatment Case-harden only Through-hardenable
Typical use Shafts, pins, weldments Gears, axles, bolts

Which should you choose

Choose 1018 when you need a mild, weldable, easily machined steel for general parts, or a core that can be case-hardened for a tough skin.

Choose 1045 when you need more strength and the ability to through-harden by heat treatment, as in gears and high-load shafts.

Carbon drives the trade-off. More carbon means more strength and hardenability but poorer weldability. 1018 welds easily; 1045 is stronger and heat-treatable.

FAQ

Can 1045 be substituted anywhere 1018 is used? Not always. 1045’s higher carbon content makes it harder to weld without preheat, so for weldments and simple low-stress parts, 1018 often remains the better and cheaper choice despite 1045’s higher strength.

Compare data sheets: 1018 Steel and 1045 Steel.

Choosing Between Them

1018 is the go-to for low-stress shafts, pins, and brackets where weldability and easy machining matter more than strength — its low carbon content welds cleanly without special preheat and case-hardens well for a wear-resistant surface over a tough core.

1045 steps up to higher-stress shafts, gears, and bolts that need more strength and wear resistance than 1018 can offer, at the cost of weldability — its higher carbon content makes it prone to cracking in the heat-affected zone unless welded with care (preheat and slow cooling).

On the machine, 1018’s softness can work against it: it’s gummy enough to form long, stringy chips and build up on the tool if cutting parameters aren’t sharp and fast. 1045 cuts cleaner, with better chip control, since its added carbon makes it less ductile and more prone to shearing off in a controlled chip.

Scroll to Top

The calculators and tools on Formula Factory are provided for general guidance and informational purposes only. Results are estimates based on standard formulas and the values you enter — they do not constitute professional engineering, electrical, or architectural advice. Always verify calculations with a qualified professional before making decisions for any safety-critical, code-compliance, or commercial application. Formula Factory makes no representations or warranties as to the accuracy or completeness of any result, and accepts no liability for errors, omissions, or any outcomes arising from reliance on this information.